Chris
McDonnell, UK
christymac733@gmail.com
Previous articles by Chris Comments
welcome here Telling someone's story Our natural
curiosity leads in many directions. We tell stories about others, we
listen to narratives of their lives, we read about other people.
Sometimes it frivolous, of little long-term importance, a passing thought,
here today, gone tomorrow. That is the stuff of newspapers anxious for the
immediate story that fuels current interest which quickly fades. But not always. A
biography that is worth its salt, is both informative and analytic. It
seeks to explore a life through balanced research with opinions checked
and sourced as far as possible. There has to be integrity in the resultant
publication, a respect for relationships in the quest for truth. A biography has
to ask a number of questions, where specific events took place, when they
took place and in what circumstances, what actually happened, why did it
happen and what were the consequences? To begin with,
what is the reason for writing at all? Usually biographies are written
about a person of some significance, someone already known for their
contribution, someone about whom we would like to hear greater detail. The
great and the good whose story we feel is attractive, or those whose lives
have in some way affected society in a detrimental manner. Our curiosity
gets the better of us. It is a mistake
to consider the Gospel narratives as biographies of Jesus of Nazareth;
that they are not. They are part of a scriptural story of the encounter
between God and humankind. The Gospels are
full of chronological holes, with no detail between the birth narrative,
the flight into Egypt and the presentation in the temple. Then there is
the long silence before the public ministry of Jesus. They are not the
story of his life, rather a development of the scriptural revelation by
God through the Christ. Their background
is very different, written as they were so many years later and without
the resources that biographers have at their disposal. They unwrap a
teaching about a way of life, an intention of purpose that brings the
story of salvation to our attention in a strong and meaningful manner.
They teach us how to be in relationship with each other and with God. They
are certainly not a series of day to day stories about Jesus of Nazareth,
but rather about his relationship with the Father and our relationship
with God. Scripture and Tradition are two channels of Revelation.
The Council speaks of God as the only source of anything. The
Gospels teach us how to 'be' in the manner in which we 'do'.
Each of us writes our own story by the manner in which we live the Gospel. A good biography
is informative, tells a story in language that holds our attention, a
story in which we feel assured that truth is being told, that is reliably
sourced, a story that hangs together. We come away from reading it with a
greater sense of knowledge and understanding, a deeper appreciation of the
journey that someone else has followed, with all its pitfalls. Having just
finished a biography of Sylvia Plath - the Silent Woman - by Janet
Malcolm, I was struck by the complexities she describes in Plath's
relationship with the poet Ted Hughes and the manner in which other
biographers have approached the same subject. It is a very informative
book not only for the light it shines on her life but the analysis it
offers of biographical writing. The biographer
has a fine line to follow, respecting the feelings of others, relatives,
friends and associates of their subject yet needing to write an account
that is truthful and to the best of their knowledge accurate. There is
always the need for balanced writing where the edge of privacy is
respected and permission to quote from difficult sources is sought. Some people have
more than one biographer when a number of different individuals take it
upon themselves to put pen to paper. Some might be close friends who want
to tell their story of a particular relationship, maybe only writing a
brief memoir that highlights a particular event. Such material becomes a
valued archive for others who want to examine in greater detail and in a
dispassionate manner a life and its consequences. Each brings to the table
their own perspective and it inevitably influences their writing. It is then that
the quality and veracity of source material becomes important. How far can
the story being told be trusted? Where is the evidence? The subject may of
course still be alive, so the question of their involvement in the text
arises. How far is the
biographer being influenced in order to present a flattering portrait? Stories of our
lives live on in the memory of family and friends, each of us on our own
particular journey, a path littered with joys and tears, one step at a
time. END
September 4, 2019

===============