2014-04-19 In one of his
"Joshua" books, Joseph Girzone uses the phrase:
"The evil of compulsory celibacy"
The articles below spell out this
evil.
Please notify of other articles which can
be added to this file: jdwomi@gmail.com
August
28, 2013: Trouble
with celibacy in the church in Africa
(and not just Africa - see comments)
July
26, 2013: Has God already
answered prayers for vocations?
Will we continue to dig for vocations to the priesthood with broken spades?
Will we keep praying for vocations when perhaps God has answered our prayers?
Do we continue to refuse what God is offering and what the Spirit is saying to
the Churches now?”
May 24, 2013: Forced celibacy and its consequences
March 31, 2013: UK MPs letter to Pope: end compulsory celibacy
March 22, 2013: Pope Francis: open to change in celibacy rule?
March 11, 2013: Conclave and celibacy (ABC)
March 9, 2013: Celibacy's Cross (Tablet)
March 5, 2013: The wages of celibacy
Feb 24, 2013: Scotland's Cardinal O'Brien: new pope should review marriage ban on priests
Feb
19, 2013: Radical Benedict Michael Mullins (Eureka
Street)
If a pope can resign, compulsory celibacy can be
consigned
Dec 23, 2012: Celibacy and the Catholic Church (ABC Radio)
Dec 1, 2012: Three letters re celibacy (Tablet)
Nov
22: Look East for reason why celibacy vow should be axed
While
we should be careful not to confuse correlation with causation, one compelling
question cannot be avoided - why do Eastern Catholics and other churches with
married clergy rarely encounter claims of child sex abuse?
Nov
21, 2012: Vilification of abusers won't contribute to solution
John C. Seitz, review of CHILD
SEXUAL ABUSE AND THE CATHOLIC CHURCH: GENDER, POWER, AND ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE
by Marie Keenan
This
latter section of the book develops several themes relevant to the rise of abuse
in Roman Catholic settings. Her focus is on seminary culture and education (in
the period before the 1990s) and the kind of living it enabled and disabled. In
these spaces priests learned to fear sexuality, disavow their bodies and
emotions, bury non-priestly components of themselves, and adapt to emotionally
isolated and lonely lives.
....These
conditions, along with sexual immaturity fostered by lifelong silence
surrounding sexuality, helped produce priests who had an “emotional
congruence” with children. Keenan sees perpetrators of abuse tragically
seeking to navigate their emotional tempests in the presence and with the bodies
of young people, whom abusers saw as equal, if easily silenced, partners.
Nov 15, 2012: Bishop
Geoffrey Robinson: Confronting the culture of abuse in the Catholic Church
See No. 5: A culture of celibacy
Oct 22, 2012: Victorian abuse inquiry: One in 20 priests an abuser
(The Age)
Professor Cahill: called for married priests, as
are being allowed now in the Anglican ordinariate within the Catholic Church,
as a "circuit-breaker" that would reduce child sex abuse
Oct, 2012: Petition to ordain married men (Tony Hoey, UK)
Sep 6, 2012: Catholic Seminaries, the inside story (AW Richard Sipe)
My conclusion from the inside: Not more than one in 20 seminarians ordained today is equipped to hear Confessions or counsel penitents or parishioners. Not one in 10 seminarians ordained today is qualified to preach.August
13, 2012: My calling to the clerical culture Don
Fausel (per Catholica)
"Describe and analyzes my experiences as a
seminarian, when I was being indoctrinated into the clerical culture and as a
priest when I became part of that culture. The anecdotes I related were not
intended to represent all clerics, but to provide readers with one man's
perspective, with the hope that they would be able to see how it was possible
for a sincere, but naïve and psychosexually immature individual to actually
become part of the clerical culture"
July
15, 2012: A married deacon can be a father but not "Fr."
Brian Eyre, a Catholic married priest in Recife, Brazil, argues
that bishops should ordain mature married men to the priesthood. He believes the
existence of married deacons will lead many to ask why the married cannot be
priests (ACP)
July
7, 2012: Nothing sacred about celibacy Adele Horin
(SMH)
"It is hard to avoid the conclusion that the unique factor of a celibate,
all-male priesthood
has contributed to the church's woes, and to the woes inflicted on its
victims"
June
14, 2012: British historian: Church has not learned from abuse in past centuries Jonathan
Luxmoore (NCR)
(historical link between compulsory
celibacy and sexual abuse by clergy)
June 1, 2012: A lament for those who left the priesthood Tom McMahon (Catholica)
May 17, 2012: History of celibacy in the Catholic Church Thomas O'Loughlin
May 12, 2012: Final paragraph's of this article by Wilfred Harrington O.P.
May 7, 2012: Brian Coyne's comment re case of Fr Oliver O'Grady, USA (final paragraph) (Catholica)
May 1, 2012: Celibacy for priests has to die Fr Michael Kelly SJ (Hoopla)
March 9, 2012: Brian Coyne's comment re case of Fr Neil Byrne, Brisbane (Catholica)
July
8, 2011: Compulsory celibacy as a condition of ministry is evil & leads to
malevolent consequences
Michael Parer (Catholica)
Previous file on optional celibacy - has many articles
----------------