Desmond O’Donnell is an Oblate priest and a registered psychologist in
Dublin
Notes from ‘JESUS – An Historical Approximation’
by Jose Pagola. (Convivium
Press 2009 ISBN 978-1-934996-09-6)
“Many
good men and women live on the epidermis of faith, nourished by a conventional
Christianity. They find religious security in the belief and practices that are
within their reach, but they do not live in joyful relationship with Jesus
Christ. They have heard of him since they were children but they are not seduced
or enamoured by what they know of him. Meeting Jesus can transform their lives.
I know how tempting it is to live correctly within the church without
worrying about the one thing Jesus sought; the kingdom of God and its
justice………… We have to return to the roots, to the experience that set
off the long chain reaction. It does no good to confess Jesus as God incarnate
if we never try to find out what this man who revealed God to us was like, how
he lived and acted Nothing can be more important to the Church than knowing,
loving and following Jesus Christ more faithfully….”
“An encounter with Jesus is not the fruit of historical research or of doctrinal reflection. It happens only through personal commitment and faithful following.
We begin to encounter Jesus
· when we begin to trust God as he did,
· when we believe in love as he did,
· when we look at people as he did,
· when we confront life and death with hope as he did,
·
when we pass on the contagion of the Good News
as he did” (p.
27,8)
Nazareth,
was an unknown town
Jesus’s name
was Yeshua (Yahweh
saves) and he called his
parents Imma and Abba - Mum and
Dad. He had four brothers and some sisters. Aramaic was his maternal language.
He probably had some knowledge of Hebrew which the Scribes knew well. If he
worked in the nearby city of
To leave
one’s family was
very serious and a possible dishonour to the family. Family was everything. He
is not moving to a new trade or place of work, or to seek out a teacher of the
Torah, or to visit the
John the
Baptiser
(submerger) left the
Around 27 AD,
in his search for his mission, Jesus is baptised by John and has a powerful
experience of God’s Spirit – ‘You
are my beloved Son……’. Later Jesus leaves John’s group to take up
John’s mission with a group whom he invited to join him in preaching the
irruption of the reign of God. Jesus
invites everyone into total trust in a Father God. He touches and heals people
whom no one else would approach. He embraces children and welcomes their
mothers.
The reign of
God
is already here - ‘among you’ (Lk.
17.21). Jesus experiences it. It is
not an intimate spiritual reality, but a transformation which involves the whole
of life and of society. It liberates people from whatever dehumanizes them or
causes them suffering. The reign of God has no centre of power or control; it
exists wherever good things happen. God is coming not to destroy people but to
destroy evil. Yet, Jesus never calls God ‘king’ which might suggest force;
it is a reign of gentleness and of goodness.
Jesus is communicating his own experience of a compassionate God who
cares more about people’s lives – ‘go
and tell John what you hear and see….blind, lame, lepers, deaf, poor have good
news brought to them’ -
than about ‘religious’ issues which lay beyond
their understanding. Where
the weak and the marginalised are brought to the centre, there is the reign of
God. He is offering shalom ie. perfect
wellbeing. God defends those who most need it. Jesus is calling people to change
their way of thinking and acting, not just to expel the Romans or to live in a
desert community or to live ritual purity as the Pharisees suggested. He sees
the growth of an inequality which favours
the minority in the
Jesus is
not a mystic in search of personal harmony.
He is seeking God’s power as ‘the
power of salvation’ for his people. Like God, he suffers at the suffering
of his people. He experiences total trust in the nearness of God who would bring
justice and salvation – the reign of God – to suffering people. He parts
company with the
He
is not a teacher of the law, nor does he tell people to return to the law. He
calls everyone to go beyond the law and to become like little children (simple,
sincere and spontaneous)*. What God wants is the good of the people. Jesus never
invites people to do penance with the ascetic rituals and actions that the
prophets called for. The
His message is that God is good and that his goodness fills everything and it erupts in human life. But people were expecting something more spectacular – the arrival of God as a great, a powerful event. But, Jesus says that God is acting in small and insignificant ways like seeds or yeast or a widow’s coin or hidden treasure or in a forgiving father or in good food, music and dancing or in rewarding latecomers, or in a boy’s gift of small cakes, or in welcoming corrupt tax collectors, or in eating with the rejected, or in a healing Samaritan, or in a caring shepherd, or in a woman finding a lost coin, or in a forgiving employer, or in visiting the sick and the imprisoned, or in a drink for the thirsty, or in food for beggars, or in touching lepers, or in eating with everyone, or in giving sight to the blind, or in constant mutual forgiveness, or in hugging children, or in defending mothers, or in a foot washing prostitute or in enjoying Springtime. He asks them to give up the image of a great, powerful and terrible God. (When asked by his followers to teach them pray, he does not say, ‘pray like this, Almighty God who are in heaven…’.*
Something mysterious is happening at the heart of human existence, expressing itself in compassion, not in law or ritual or in a holy community living apart. God is quietly and secretly acting at the inner core of people’s lives. His parables are meant to continually awaken the experience they provoked when he spoke them. Jesus is calling all to accept a new way of doing things in the reign of God where compassion is the normal way to live. He tells about the God of compassion not the God of the holiness of purity. When Jesus touches the leper, he does not become impure; the leper becomes pure. Holiness is compassionate love, not of separation from everything impure. Mercy takes the place of holiness as then understood.
A God of vengeance who had been punishing his people for their sin through the Romans, was expected by all at that time, to rescue them. Everyone was expecting God to act against the colonizers. Even the Psalms prayed for a God of vengeance. Jesus is rejecting the psalms of vengeance and this teaching is completely unsupported by much biblical tradition. He is against the ideology of the Essenes who prayed for the future victory of the sons of light against the sons of darkness. He sees love of enemies as the way back to God. Jesus is thinking of a few, of minorities acting as sons and daughters of God, of authentic witnesses to God’s kingdom in the midst of an unjust and violent world.
He is not thinking of large institutions (not ‘Where two or three hundred are gathered in my name’). His followers are mustard seeds or yeast or grains of salt, but their lives will always be on a cross – ‘You must take up your cross daily and follow me’. Jesus’ disciples are to be a light that proclaims God’s new world in a clear and credible way. (p.257)
God is coming as a God of suffering and a healing God, not as a God of righteousness. (A God of powerless defenceless loving, of suffering love)* Jesus does not look first at sinners who need to be called to conversion but at those who suffer and who yearn for a healthier happier life. At that time, illness had been seen from the religious viewpoint, not from the medical. For the Semites, health and sickness came from God and the sick were not allowed into the temple. (Jesus first says to the paralyzed man ‘Your sins are forgiven’ before he heals him)*. Jesus gives the sick something the doctors could not offer – a new relationship with God. His healings are not isolated acts but part of his proclamation of the reign of God. They are signs of the new world. His followers must go on bringing God’s compassion - ‘as your Father is compassionate’ - into the world.
Jesus surprising approach to sin is different from that of the Baptist’s who does not scandalize anyone in his condemnation. Sin is more than an individual activity; people absorb it from the social and religious environment. And there is room in the reign of God for sinners. Jesus does not address them as a judge but with a father’s compassionate love. He had meals with them. Sinners were people who deliberately violated the Covenant and did not repent. Sinners were not those ignorant of the law, or those who did not purify themselves or those who had despised occupations. These groups were despised but not regarded as sinners**. Jesus offers forgiveness wrapped in friendly acceptance to all. For the Pharisees, sinners must offer expiatory sacrifice in the temple, return to the law and make reparation. But Jesus accepts sinners without first requiring repentance as traditionally understood. and without submitting to baptism as the Baptist demanded. (Zaccheus* got acceptance and forgiveness, communion and companionship before he confessed his sins) Forgiveness motivates love.*** Jesus accepts people as they are. He offers them face-to-face compassion, not tablets of the law. Prostitutes, he says are getting into heaven before the Pharisees.
**Harrington, the NJBC and other scriptural scholars hold that sinners were those who because of their lifestyle, occupations or actions were looked upon as not meeting religious standards of purity. eg donkey/camel drivers, sailors, casters, shepherds, physicians & butchers (blood-letters), tanners, bath attendants, tax collectors and foreigners. Pagola (p. 196) says that they were people with clear sociological characteristics !
*** ‘Her many
sins have been forgiven; hence she has shown great love’ (Lk.7.47)
Jesus rejects the stereotypes of woman – property of men, sources of temptation, impure etc. They were marginalised in many ways - not obliged to recite the Shema or make pilgrimages, to join men in the temple, to speak to men in public, enclosed in the house, defenceless in court – profoundly marginalised. (Rabbis prayed ‘I thank thee Yahweh, thou hast not made me a dog, a Samaritan or a woman’)*. Jesus never warns men about seductive women but about their own lust. Women are his friends: Mary from Magdala, Martha and Mary from Bethany, a sick syro-phoenician woman, despised prostitutes, faithful followers like Salome. They were not called disciples because the Aramaic word was always a masculine noun.
Jesus does not confuse love of God with love of neighbour; they are not the same thing-(p.249) Love of God cannot be reduced to love of neighbour. The love of neighbour is not in itself love of God. The love of God and his will holds primacy. We pray to God, not to our neighbour; we await the reign of God, not that of our brothers and sisters. The first commandment does not dissolve into human solidarity. In God’s reign the neighbour takes the place of the law. The reign of God is not a metaphor. It simply means living compassionate – (cum patiar Latin to suffer with*) - love of neighbour in every situation. For Jesus the family does not come first. Service to the reign of God – God’s plan - is first.
Jesus had four kinds of followers: 1) The curious crowds, 2) those who welcomed him into their homes 3) those who travelled with him, and finally 4) his closed circle of apostles (Jesus never used the word). Jesus chooses twelve men with whom he would start the movement that gave rise to Christianity. There are no Scribes or priests among the 12, and they were probably all Galileans. Peter stood out. Jesus’ close followers do not come for admission into a school. He calls them out of their homes but he does not lead them like a rabbi expounding the law, rather as a prophet filled with God’s spirit. Their goal is not to achieve the status of a Rabbi, but to share an uncertain future while he tells them frequently ’Do not be afraid’ and ‘Do not be anxious’. Neither are they with him to learn or study his ideas, but rather to follow him, to live as he did, accepting and building the reign of God. Their relationship is a personal bond with someone who is initiating them into God’s plan. In his movement, no one lords it over others; there is no priests-laypeople division. ‘I am among you as one who serves’
Jesus
teaches clearly that everyone has direct, immediate access to God the Father of
all.. Jesus is not their father, but their brother – ‘Go and tell my brothers….’. He does not lead them into the
desert nor try to form a ritually pure group, nor start another
Jesus never
explained his idea of God or a doctrine about God;
for him God is not a theory. God was an experience that transformed him to
encourage a happier life for everyone. Jesus was born into a nation of
believers. God was
The God of Jesus does not reveal himself as mystery, but as a father, and Jesus’ life is one of total trust seeking God’s will without reservation despite real temptations not to do so. The word obedience never occurs in Jesus’ sayings. Rather than obeying God’s law, he identifies with God and seeks his will. He seeks intimacy with God in silent prayerful encounters. His experience is Abba., not ‘Yahweh’, ‘the Heavens’, ‘the Power’, ‘the Place’, ‘the one living in the Temple’, ’the Lord’ - words commonly used for God. In the Old Testament, ‘Father’ had been in use for God to emphasise his authority but Abba was seldom used. For Jesus what defines God is not his power, nor his wisdom which could produce a religion of rules, harshness, merits and punishment, but his care which seduces and invites to closeness and which steps into the world to humanize it. His reign is an energy for transformation. Suffering, disease, misfortune, punishment, tests and purifications are not God’s will. That is why Jesus unmasks a false religion that is not at the service of life. God cannot be monopolised by a religious elite, by any religious system or priestly class. Authority is not to rule, but to serve, to do good. c.f Pagola’s comments on the Our Father (p.313-6)
The freedom
Jesus offers was disturbing & dangerous to religious, political &
economic
power at the time – the educated Pharisees, the aristocratic Scribes, the
ascetic Essenes, the controlling Priests (and the dagger carrying Zealots*). The
Pharisees interpreted, explained, applied and policed the law but they did not
instigate Jesus’ execution. The
In
the month of Nisan (Mar-Apr) he freely goes up to
He arranges a farewell dinner. It was not a Passover meal or the Passover night. This meal reminds Jesus of the final banquet in the reign of God. ‘This is my body (I myself in Aramaic). He invites his disciple to drink from a single cup, his cup, the cup of salvation shed for all(best translation). In repeating this meal later in christian communities, they will be nourished by his memory and his presence. He washes their feet – unthinkable from a host or from anyone at a festive meal - and told them to do the same as slaves of one another.
It was the
temple police who arrested Jesus
and who took him to Caiaphas’ house where the Sanhedrin presided over the
trial. He dominated the religious and politician scene in
Crucifixion,
although common, was a terrible experience (450 slaves in
How does Jesus feel when he sees the failure of his plan for the reign of God, the abandonment by his closest, and the hostility surrounding him ? In the end he comes back to his original experience of God - Abba ? But his final words, ‘Father, into you hands….’ are probably reflections by the Christian community who put a psalm on his lips. Yet the ‘Eloi, Eloi….’ may have come from Jesus’ lips.
Will God leave
this man
in the land of the dead ? (p. 387+) Something happens to the disciples which is
hard to explain. Despite their flight, fear and locked doors, they now leave the
safety of
Jesus ‘risen’: When they speak of the risen Christ, it is more than saying that their faith has been awakened. It is the event which pulls them out of confusion and it forms their new relationship with Jesus. Neither is the resurrection the reanimation of a cadaver like Lazarus or Jairus’ daughter or the young man at Naim. Lazarus returned to his everyday life but the risen Jesus enters into the land of freedom and light. Jesus does not return to this life; he enters definitively into the life of God never to die again. It is the same Jesus but in a new existence. Jesus is raised with a body that expresses and give fullness to his whole earthy life.
For Semites, the body is the whole person. They cannot imagine Jesus risen without a body, but it is not a physical flesh-and-blood body subject to the power of death. It is a glorified body that expresses and give fulfilment to his whole earthly life. It is a spiritual body that is enlivened by the vital and creative force of God. He is now filled with God’s creative power. God is beginning a new creation in the risen Jesus. Paul says that he is filled with divine power and can be called Lord – the word used by Greek-speaking Christians for Yahweh.
We cannot penetrate the meaning of the disciples’ new experience by using historical methods, but their faith did not come from nowhere. The resurrection opens them to a new and surprising experience of his presence in their midst. The process is rich and complex, made up of questions, reflections, unexpected events and amazing experiences of faith. All this awakens in them a new faith in Jesus, their growing sense of his presence with them and in them after his death.
There
was an ancient Jewish belief in life after death, but a relatively new faith in
resurrection, was emerging at this time. They believed Martyrs and people of
good will change from being dust to being like stars.
Jesus and his disciples certainly shared this faith.
But the early resurrection of one person before the end of time was
something new. A resurrection that would only affect each one individually had
little to do with salvation for the rest of humanity.
But now the disciples were experiencing God’s liberating irruption to
establish the reign of God here and now. God was making the risen Jesus present
in their hearts. Words also cannot
tell us how the disciples perceived this presence. The message is not that Jesus
appeared but that he is acting within his disciples. Paul discovered ‘the power of his resurrection’ and said ‘I live now, now not I but it is Christ Jesus living in me’(
The empty tomb
does not play a significant role in the birth of faith in the risen Christ. It
is mentioned first in the 60s. It is
unclear if the empty tomb story is history or a literary composition, but there
are ample reasons to affirm it. The faith of the disciples is inspired not by
the empty tomb but by their encounters with him, full of life after his death.
They now feel empowered and motivated to return to
Who is this Jesus ? Out of the experience of resurrection, the disciples look back on his life. The Gospels reveal more than Jesus’ words; they tell us about his actions and his life which reveal the saving presence of God living in the flesh of his Son. The disciples are so sure that Jesus is alive, that they feel free to attribute to him words that express his spirit, even though they are not the exact words he spoke.
MARK writes a suspenseful gospel asking ‘who is this man ?’ He answers that it is in the abandonment of the crucifixion that one can confess Jesus, not as the powerful Son of an omnipotent God He is not the powerful and glorious Messiah they expect, but as a crucified Son given by his father, out of love to humanity. Disciples will understand who he is when they take up his cross, learn to be servants of all and follow him to crucifixion. Filled with the Spirit, his life becomes a source of life, healing and forgiveness for true disciples. Jesus is God’s Son and God’s good news bringing salvation, in contrast to the Roman emperor who called himself ‘divifilus’ (divine son).
MATTHEW was
written after the destruction of the temple when the rabbis were trying to
restore Judaism and the Law of Moses. At the same time the Christians were
establishing Christian communities among the diaspora. These communities are
identified with the risen Jesus who is not a false prophet but the new Moses,
the Messiah. He is God’s Son giving birth to the New Israel. He takes the
place of the temple and is Emmanuel - God with us - until the end of ages. Jesus
is the saving presence of God in the world forever. ‘Where
two or three are gathered in my name, there I am among them’
(Mt. 18.20) Perhaps it came from an old Jewish text which says ‘Where
two or three are gathered to study Torah, there is the shekina(presence) of
God’
For Matthew, the law of Christ can be summarised:
1) Do to others what you would have them do to you.
2) Love the Lord your God and your neighbour as yourself.
3) Justice, mercy and faith are the weightier things of the law.
For him, The Church is the community formed by those who hear Jesus’ call and keep it. It is built on Peter, and everyone is a disciple, a brother or sister. Everyone in the church must care for those who need it most, ‘the little ones’, the neglected, the marginalised, and practise loving correction and forgiveness of one another.
LUKE also tells us that Jesus is the Messiah and Lord, but he stresses that he is Saviour, the salvation of God. The Saviour spreads joy and his healings inspire praise. He is God’s compassion. Jesus is the today of salvation. He is the incarnation of God’s mercy for anyone who is ‘lost’ or ‘poor’, with special care for women. Jesus is the bearer of the Spirit of God. He was raised by God’s Spirit and Luke encourages all to see that same Spirit always giving him life.
JOHN shows that the disciples are remembering Jesus words and action in the light of the resurrection. The Paraclete is reminding them of ‘all that I have said to you’. It is not the story of another prophet, but of the Word of God made flesh in Jesus. He is the messenger and the revealer of the Father, showing us the mystery of the God whom no one has ever seen. Love alone motivates the gift of God in Jesus. His miracles are signs revealing the power and compassion of God. His commandment to love as God loves says everything that Jesus has to convey from his intimacy with the Father. (Jn. 15. 4-9, 10-12) Now disciples are not servants but friends of God. Jesus is bread, light, gate, good shepherd, the way, truth, life and the vine in which they must live.
The Christians looked for NAMES FOR JESUS after the resurrection experience.
Messiah or
Christ
is used from the beginning. They were called Christian (Messianists) first in
The Son of Man, the New Man was used by Jesus to emphasize his human nature. No one else called him this. He also spoke about the Son of Man seated at the right hand of the power, with a probably reference to Daniel 7.13,14. Paul refers to Jesus as the New Adam where grace abounds over sin. This title soon fell into disuse.
High Priest
in Hebrews was used to encourage converted Jews (priests ?*) probably in
Lord
was used of Jesus from the beginning. It
is not only an honorific title. God made him Lord from the moment of his
resurrection. Foreign Gods were called Kyrios(lord) but no one can call Jesus
Lord except by the power of the Holy Spirit.
He is not Lord in order to dominate, rule or control but to enliven, to
give life. Christians must live for and die for him
(Ro. 14.8,9).
They prayed ‘Come, Lord Jesus, come’
Incarnate Word of God as in John’s prologue where it echoes the Greek word ‘logos’ (meaning). The Jews however said that God has no image, only a voice. It was the ‘sophia’ Wisdom of God which gives meaning to life. God looks at people as Jesus does; he accepts, heals, defends, loves, forgives as Jesus does. Jesus is God, speaking to us in the frailty & vulnerability in this one human being.
Son of God
was used very early on in all communities, and it surely came from their memory
of Jesus who called God his Abba. At
the same time it suggested the ineffable mystery of God who had raised him by
infusing his own life in him. In the
Old Testament, the people of
In seeking the risen Lord today, the Emmaus story guides us. After the resurrection the disciples began to explore the mystery of Jesus in the light of faith, often with difficulty. What can people who did not live with Jesus do to meet him today ?. The Emmaus story tells us that to meet Jesus today, one needs to 1) come together with a few others seekers, in his name 2) to read the Gospels and to remember his crucifixion - listening from within. But that is not enough. 3) We also need to experience the Eucharistic meal in order to recognise the presence of the risen Lord, not only as one whose words shine a light on our lives but as one who feeds us at his Table.
After the crucifixion Mary Magdalene was sad and desolate and looking for Jesus. She cannot live without him. We need to undertake an inner search also. But that may not be enough. Like her we have to hear our own name on his lips, to be called by him in person. Then our life changes from the bottom up. We discover like Mary, that Jesus is more than a teacher. He is the Son of God going to his Father and to ours. She has to learn to live with the risen Lord but without his physical presence, and to embrace him in her brothers and sisters. Together we all make up the family of God. Jesus Christ is our hope. With him and through him we will come one day into the bosom of the Father.
Here is what we must do, the journey we must take:
We must put Jesus at the centre of Christianity. Everything else comes later. We Christians must confess Jesus as Son of God. Doctrine alone will not nourish our faith nor can we live by a set of truths as our only motivation. We need a living connection with him and to continue to know him better. We are in danger of turning Jesus in to a mere object of worship, an icon to venerate with a majestic face. Instead, we need to see and meet him up close.