Darlene's previous articles 

Darlene Starrs (Canada)      

2015-08-03 

Ending Clericalism?

(Comments welcome here)

  Darlene's background



 

 

You will find on this website a recent article by Donald Cozzens suggesting we end clericalism in the Church. Peculiarly, Jesus had serious misgivings about the religious leaders of his day and for similar reasons.

What is clericalism? I describe it as primarily an Arrogance of heart and mind which finds expression in various words and actions, particularly, affecting those of us in the pew. Clericalism is difficult to define as Father Donald Cozzens remarks, but, you know it, when you encounter it. It is experienced as patronization, diminution, and dismissal. I suggest that women have felt the "bite" of clericalism more often and with greater intensity, and is evidenced by the women’s struggle for full inclusion in ordained ministry.

Donald Cozzens tells us that clericalism is not found only with the priests, deacons and bishops. No, clericalism, potentially, may be attributed to any and everyone who has a professional position and vested role in the Church, and who places themselves over and above the people they are serving.

Pope Francis has directed many comments, including a blistering speech to the Curia last December, about clericalism. We know that from the time of his papacy, Pope Francis, discarded many of the perks and luxuries of living at the Vatican and being the Roman Pontiff. He also repeatedly reminds the priests, bishops, and cardinals, that they are to serve with love and humility.

Even with Pope Francis’s words on clericalism, I maintain, that as long as there is a Church organization and the professionalization of Church ministry, there also will exist clerical arrogance somewhere and in some way. Ending clericalism is a lofty ideal, but hardly realistic. It does need to be addressed however, as clericalism, is particularly harmful, if it blocks the Lord’s Way and Will.

--------------